If you’ve just paid your public liability renewal and you’re wondering whether it goes on the tax return — the short answer is yes, almost every insurance policy you take out for the business is an allowable expense.
But the line between “business insurance” and “personal insurance” trips people up, and it’s drawn in a slightly surprising place. There’s also a catch on the other side: deduct the premium now, and HMRC taxes the payout later.
1. The basic rule: business policies are deductible
HMRC’s allowable expenses guidance is unusually plain about this: “You can claim for any insurance policy for your business, for example public liability insurance.” Professional indemnity premiums are listed explicitly too.
The underlying test is the same wholly and exclusively rule that governs every expense: the policy must be taken out for the purposes of the trade. A policy that covers a business risk passes; a policy that covers you as a person fails.
2. What counts as a business policy
These are all straightforwardly deductible:
- Public liability — covers injury or property damage claims from clients or the public
- Professional indemnity — covers claims arising from your advice or work
- Employer’s liability — covers employee injury claims (and is legally required if you employ anyone — see below)
- Premises and contents — cover for business premises, tools, stock and equipment
- Business interruption / loss of profits — policies that pay out when a business event stops you trading (BIM45510)
- Key person cover — term insurance on an employee’s life or health is deductible if the sole purpose is protecting trading income and the policy has no investment element (BIM45525)
Car and van insurance for a business vehicle is deductible too, but it sits inside the vehicle costs rules — whether you claim it depends on which method you’re using. See our car expenses guide for that decision.
3. What isn’t deductible: policies that protect you personally
This is where most of the confusion lives. Per HMRC’s insurance guidance (BIM45560), premiums you pay for life, accident or sickness cover on yourself are not deductible — that includes most income protection and permanent health policies, plus personal accident plans. The reasoning: the policy protects you, not the trade. If you’re too ill to work, the payout replaces your income personally, which fails the wholly and exclusively test.
The consolation: because the premium wasn’t deductible, the payout is generally tax-free.
There’s one genuine exception worth knowing. Per BIM45565, a sickness policy that specifically covers business costs while you’re incapacitated — paying for a locum to cover your work, or keeping fixed overheads running — is deductible. These are mostly marketed at doctors and dentists, but the rule applies to any sole trader. The dividing line is what the payout reimburses: business costs (deductible) vs your lost income (not).
4. The catch: deductible premiums mean taxable payouts
Per BIM45500, the tax treatment is symmetrical: if the premium was deductible, the payout is trading income. Claimed £400 of professional indemnity premium against your profits, then received a £5,000 payout when a client claim settled? The payout goes on your return as income.
The reverse holds too — premiums you couldn’t deduct (personal income protection, life cover) produce tax-free benefits. It’s a coherent system, just one that surprises people who didn’t expect to declare an insurance payout.
The fee protection trap
Tax investigation insurance — sometimes called fee protection — has a specific rule that catches people out. Per BIM46452, premiums are only deductible if the underlying accountancy costs would themselves have been allowable. And accountancy fees for fixing careless or deliberate errors aren’t allowable.
So if your fee protection policy covers the accountant’s fees for an enquiry that turns up careless or deliberate inaccuracies — which most off-the-shelf policies do — the whole premium is disallowable, and you can’t even apportion it. If you’ve bought investigation cover, check the policy wording before you claim the premium. For what actually triggers an enquiry, see our guide on what triggers an HMRC investigation.
5. When insurance is legally required
There’s no general legal duty for sole traders to hold business insurance — but two narrow requirements exist:
- Employer’s liability. The moment you employ anyone — even part-time, temporary or casual help — you must hold at least £5 million of employer’s liability cover from an authorised insurer. The fine for being uninsured is £2,500 per day. There’s an exemption for employees who are close family members (spouse, parent, child, sibling and so on), per GOV.UK’s employer’s liability guidance. If it’s just you, you don’t need it at all.
- Business motor insurance. A social and domestic policy doesn’t cover driving for work — even a single client visit needs business use cover. This isn’t a tax rule, it’s the Road Traffic Act.
Public liability and professional indemnity aren’t legally required — but they’re often commercially required. Clients, venues and local authorities routinely ask for £1-5 million of public liability cover before they’ll let you on site, and many professional bodies and client contracts mandate PI cover. The premiums are deductible either way.
6. How to claim it
Under the cash basis (the default for sole traders since April 2024), you deduct the premium when you pay it. An annual policy paid in November 2026 lands in your 2026/27 return; monthly premiums are deducted as they’re paid.
Keep the policy schedule and proof of payment — a certificate of insurance plus the bank statement entry is enough. You don’t need a special invoice format; the same records standard applies as for any other expense.
The bottom line
- Any business policy is an allowable expense — public liability, professional indemnity, employer’s liability, premises, tools and business interruption cover all reduce your taxable profit.
- Personal protection policies don’t qualify — income protection, personal accident and life insurance protect you, not the trade. But policies covering business costs like a locum can be deductible.
- Deductible premium = taxable payout. The tax treatment follows through on both sides.
- Fee protection needs a policy-wording check — if it covers fees arising from careless or deliberate errors, the premium isn’t deductible at all.
- Employer’s liability is the one legal requirement — £5 million of cover the day you employ anyone who isn’t close family, on pain of £2,500-a-day fines.
For the complete list of what sole traders can and can’t claim, see our allowable expenses guide. For how insurance fits alongside the other levers that cut your tax bill, see our reduce your Self Assessment tax bill hub.