Pie Tax makes a claim that sounds too good to be true for a site like this one: a Self Assessment app that files your return to HMRC for free. Not a free trial, not a free tier with filing locked behind a paywall — free filing, full stop. With MTD for Income Tax now mandating digital filing for sole traders above £50,000 (and £30,000 from April 2027), a legitimately free route is worth a proper look.

This review covers what Pie actually is, what’s genuinely free versus where the money is, what it does well, and — because free software deserves the most scrutiny — where it falls short.

Affiliate disclosure: Some links below may earn us a commission at no cost to you. This doesn’t affect our recommendations — we recommend the options we think are right for sole traders, not the ones that pay the most.

1. What Pie Tax actually is

Pie isn’t accounting software in the FreeAgent/Xero sense — it’s a personal tax app. It’s designed for individuals rather than books-keepers: sole traders, landlords, freelancers, delivery drivers, people mixing PAYE work with side income. The pitch is “an accountant in your pocket” — the app shows your real-time tax position as you earn, keeps your records, and files your Self Assessment directly to HMRC when January comes.

The company behind it is Pie Money — on Companies House it appears as a UK establishment (BR025806, opened April 2023) of Dublin-based Pie Money Holdings Limited. Bank feeds run through open banking via TrueLayer (FCA-authorised; Pie acts as its agent under FRN 901096) — so you’re granting read-only transaction access, not handing over bank credentials. Pie describes itself as an HMRC-recognised software developer, and the app has crossed 100,000 downloads with strong user ratings. You can get the Pie app here.

2. What’s actually free

This is the unusual part, so it’s worth being precise. Per Pie’s pricing, the free tier includes:

  • Digital bookkeeping — open banking feeds that import and categorise transactions (“Smart Match” learns recurring ones)
  • Receipt capture and storage — snap receipts, stored against transactions
  • Invoicing — create and send invoices from the app
  • Real-time tax estimate — a running figure for what you owe, updated as transactions land
  • Multiple income streams — self-employment, property, PAYE, savings and investments aggregated into one tax position
  • Direct Self Assessment filing to HMRC — the actual submission, free
  • MTD filing — Pie’s position is that MTD compliance tools should be free, and filing capability is included at £0

For context, the other free route to this is a business bank account with built-in MTD (Monzo Lite, Starling, Tide) — but those only see the money in that account. Pie aggregates income across sources, which is the thing most free options can’t do.

3. Where the money is — the paid extras

Pie’s revenue comes from human support layered on top of the free app, sold as discrete services:

Extra Cost What it is
Tax Support £89/year Unlimited access to a dedicated tax assistant — phone, in-app chat or email — including help identifying expenses and reliefs
Tax return check £59 one-off An experienced assistant quality-checks your return before you submit
Done for you £126 one-off They prepare and file the return; you review and approve
MTD package £199/year The software plus human handling of the MTD admin

The pricing logic is sensible: the software does the mechanical work for free, and you pay only for a human’s time when you want it. £89/year for year-round tax support is cheap against the ~£600/year a sole trader accountant typically costs — see our accountant costs guide for that comparison.

4. What Pie does well

Multiple income streams. This is the real differentiator. If you’re PAYE-employed with a side business, or a landlord who also freelances, most free tools only see one account. Pie pulls your income sources together and shows the combined tax figure — including the things people forget count, like savings interest above the allowance.

The real-time tax number. Watching your liability update as income lands removes the January shock that this whole site exists to prevent. It also makes the set-aside habit trivially easy — you can see what to put away as you go.

The middle ground between DIY and an accountant. £0 software + £59 return check is a genuinely useful combination: you do the data entry all year, a human sanity-checks the return before it goes to HMRC. That’s most of the value of an accountant for a straightforward sole trader, at a tenth of the price. If you’re weighing up software versus human help, our tax service vs accountant vs software guide covers the decision properly.

Sector-specific help. The tax assistants are organised by industry — builders, couriers, landlords, creatives — so the expense advice is aimed at what you actually do rather than generic.

5. The limitations — read this before committing

It’s a tax app, not accounting software. Pie tracks income, expenses and tax — it doesn’t do the full double-entry bookkeeping, detailed reporting, or accounting integrations that FreeAgent or Xero provide. If your accountant expects to log into your ledger, or you want real accounts rather than tax records, Pie alone won’t satisfy that. A proper ledger like FreeAgent (10% off with this link — and free outright with a NatWest, RBS or Mettle business account) is the better fit there.

App-only. It’s mobile-first in the truest sense — there’s no desktop accounting suite. If you want to sit at a laptop reconciling a year’s records, this isn’t the product.

Verify MTD recognition for your filing. Pie markets free MTD filing and describes itself as HMRC-recognised, but recognition is granted per filing type — VAT, Income Tax, Self Assessment are separate. Before relying on it for your MTD for Income Tax quarterly updates, confirm it on HMRC’s compatible software list for the specific obligations you have. Do this with every provider, not just Pie — our MTD software guide explains what recognition means.

A younger product. Pie doesn’t have the two-decade track record of the big accounting platforms, and its support extras are priced to attract you into the ecosystem — expect the app to nudge you toward the paid services.

6. Who Pie Tax is right for — and who should look elsewhere

A strong fit if you: are a sole trader or landlord who wants to file on your phone for £0; mix income types (self-employment plus PAYE, property or investments); want a real-time tax figure without learning accounting; or want human backup available without paying accountant rates.

Look elsewhere if you: need full bookkeeping with reports and accountant access (FreeAgent, Xero, QuickBooks); want desktop software; are VAT-registered and need a mature VAT workflow; or have complex affairs — CIS-heavy income, partnerships, anything likely to face an enquiry — where an actual accountant earns their fee.

7. How it compares to the alternatives

Option Price What you get Best for
Pie Tax £0 (support extras £59–£199) App bookkeeping, real-time tax estimate, direct filing, multi-income aggregation Sole traders and landlords who want filing handled on a phone for free
FreeAgent via NatWest/RBS/Mettle £0 bundled (£19/mo standalone) Full double-entry ledger, reports, accountant access — but business-only view Proper bookkeeping and an accountant who can log in
Built-in bank MTD (Monzo Lite, Starling, Tide) £0 Filing from inside your banking app — but only sees that account’s transactions Simple affairs, one account, zero budget
Bridging software (123 Sheets, VitalTax, Acxite) ~£20–60/yr Spreadsheet records submitted to HMRC — more manual, no app Spreadsheet loyalists who want minimal tooling
TaxScouts/Taxfix-style services ~£120–250/return A return filed for you, no ongoing tools One-off filing with zero software involvement
An accountant ~£600/yr Filing plus real advice, planning and HMRC representation Complex affairs or anyone wanting ongoing advice

For the whole free-and-cheap field, see our cheapest MTD software for sole traders guide.

8. The bottom line

Pie Tax does something genuinely rare: it removes the price of filing entirely. A free app that keeps your records, estimates your tax in real time, aggregates multiple income streams and submits your Self Assessment to HMRC for £0 is, on the facts, the cheapest legitimate route to a filed return — and the paid extras (£59–£126) fill exactly the gap that makes people nervous about filing alone.

The trade-offs are real but specific: it’s not a full accounting ledger, it’s app-only, and you should verify its MTD recognition for your filing type before April deadlines make the question urgent. If your situation is “straightforward sole trader or landlord who wants January handled on a phone,” it earns the download.

Still deciding between software and human help? Our filing services comparison puts Pie alongside the other ways to get your return in.

Back to Self Assessment Help: Accountants & Filing Services · Back to Guide